Business plan, project or strategic plan: which one you need before you invest
In Mexico City, Bogotá, Madrid or Miami, people who decide to start a business almost always arrive with the same things: an idea, some capital and a lot of drive. And they almost always get the same advice: "write a plan."
The advice is right but incomplete. Three different documents are often confused, and each one answers a different question. Choosing the wrong one is one of the most common ways to spend time and money without moving forward.
Three tools, three questions
A business plan answers: does this business hold up?
It explains how the business will create, deliver and get paid for its value. It brings market, operations, finance and risk into one document. You need it to open a business, seek funding or bring in partners.
Project design answers: how do I turn this initiative into something others can evaluate?
It takes a specific idea (a new location, a service line, a funding proposal) and structures it with scope, owners, risks, schedule and a way to measure results. You need it when the business already exists and what must be approved or funded is a specific initiative.
Strategic planning answers: where are we going and what do we stop doing?
It defines direction, priorities, objectives and indicators for the whole organization. You need it when the business works but everyone pushes in a different direction, or everything feels urgent.
When you need them together
Often the real need crosses all three. A company that wants to grow needs to know where it is going (strategy), which initiative gets it there (project) and whether the numbers support it (business plan).
Doing them separately usually duplicates work: the same market analysis appears three times and the conclusions don't always match. It is better to design them as one engagement, with a shared base and connected deliverables.
Three signs you chose the wrong tool
- You have a long business plan but no clear decision. You probably needed strategic direction first.
- You have a well-presented project no one approves. It is probably not connected to the decision maker's priorities.
- You have an inspiring strategic plan with no numbers. You probably needed to check whether the business model supports it.
Funders ask the same questions in every country
A bank, an investor, a development fund or a partner ask, in different words, the same questions: what it really costs to deliver what you sell, how long until the first revenue, what the risks are and who is responsible for each part. Those questions don't change from one country to another; what changes are the rules, the currency and the market.
A review of research covering more than eleven thousand companies found that planning is associated with better performance, although that link alone does not prove the plan is the cause. What is certain is that a solid plan removes one reason for an evaluator to say no.
Before you invest
Before paying for any plan, answer one question: what decision do I need to make, and who else has to understand it?
If the answer is "whether to open," you need a business plan. If it is "whether this initiative gets approved," you need a project. If it is "what we prioritize," you need a strategic plan. And if it is more than one, you need all three to work together.
If the answer isn't clear, that is the first piece of work worth doing.
Related services
- Plan de Negocio · Business plan
- Diseño de Proyectos · Project design and structuring
- Planificación Estratégica · Strategic planning
- Solución Integral · Integrated planning, projects and business
Roselba Mejias, MBA · Strategic and Operational Consultant · Orlando, Florida
I work in Spanish and English with clients in the United States and Latin America.
Sources: Bplans, summary of research on planning and performance (2010 study of 11,046 companies).
